Boys Over Flowers – A Non-Kdrama Fan perspective

Posted by Jami McFeely on September 9, 2015

Reviews

image

Hi there! I’m Stephanie’s friend Jami, and I recently completed my first ever Kdrama. Obviously, I have been hearing wonderful things from Stephanie about these shows for years. I have been slowly making my way through Pasta, and enjoying it, but still have four episodes to go before it’s complete. The first 16 episodes took my husband and I over a year to watch, mostly because our streaming capabilities were very limited for a long time. I also tried watching It’s Okay, That’s Love but didn’t make it to the second episode, so my Kdrama experience has been limited at best.

Anyhow, I’ve had a little extra time at work lately and enjoy watching Netflix while taking care of busy work. And what should Netflix suggest to me a few weeks back? Boys Over Flowers — one of the early shows I remembered Stephanie talking about, so I figured “what the heck” I’ll give it a try.

I was instantly aware of the crack-tastic nature of the show. They really do a good job of pulling you in and getting you invested in the characters quickly. I found it to be very Pride and Prejudice-y at the beginning, which was a big plus: Arrogant, wealthy man taken under the spell of a poor, spitfire. Older female relation wants to block the match. He has a sweet best friend who our heroine gets along with much better than our hero. As a BBC drama lover, this was hitting all the right notes for me, however, I do think that they went a little too far making F4 unlikable at the beginning. Seriously — these guys happily drove at least one person to attempted suicide. Are we supposed to forget that just because Goo Jun Pyo’s mother never loved him?

image

However, they do get the romance and infatuation in the first half very right. Much of the credit of this goes to Lee Min Ho, who is more than up to the challenge of playing arrogant as well as lovesick. Koo Hye Sun has a lovely, warm presence and more than sells her character, but seems to have a bit of trouble selling me on the fact that she really was in love. This is made more evident in the second half of the show when they are separated and she is the one who is lovesick. Maybe it’s a Kdrama-thing? I know not to expect Sex and the City-ish passion from a Korean teen drama, but it would be nice if she didn’t look… uncomfortable… whenever they were alone. Even when she realizes that she likes him, she just never seems like she wants him to touch her in any way. Is this level of modesty consistent with all females in Kdramas or is it unique to this show?

Other stray observations:

There is no way these people are in high school. Unless they go to Rydell with Rizzo and Kenickie.

Isn’t Kpop a massive industry? Why do they only have the rights to four songs? Using the same love song for Goo Jun Pyo and Jandi as you do for Ji Hoo and his Grandfather is… odd.

No one cares about Wo Bin. Don’t half-heartedly try to give him a story at the last minute.

image

For that matter, we care less about Ji Hoo’s grandfather and Ji Yung’s pottery crush than the writers seem to think. They would have been better served to make these themes right from the beginning to get people invested.

I love the flyaway hairs and not-blindingly-white teeth on some actors. Very un-American TV. These are just “normal” beautiful people. Not beautiful people with teams of stylists to keep them looking beyond-perfect every second. It’s comforting.

While we’re at it, I also loved the blurred out brand names in the supermarket scenes. Seriously? Can you not either fill the screen with product placement or just slap pretend labels over things like we do in America? I expect blurring out in reality shows since they can’t control their environment as much as a scripted show. Strange, but oddly comforting.

I think Ji Hoo looked way cuter with his long, lighter hair.

These people never attend work. Or school. And there never seem to be any adults or authority figures on campus.

image

Characters, plotlines, and people’s motivations seem to shift with the breeze. I think that’s why the second half drags a bit because, while more focused, it’s not quite the roller coaster of activity we’ve been experiencing thus far.

All-in-all, it was definitely enjoyable, but it seemed to lose its way halfway through and forgot a bit what kind of show it was. I would have been happier if it trimmed out a few episodes and stretched out a few of the near-death experiences they crammed into the first half over more episodes. There is a lot of filler in this series, for one that moved so quickly for the first 10 episodes. So. Many. Montages. And flashbacks. By the last few episodes, we were flashing back to scenes that happened 10 minutes prior. Uhhh… I think we remember that. IT JUST HAPPENED. I’m certainly open to watching more Kdramas, though there is so much fantastic television right now that I doubt it will ever take over a significant portion of my viewing. I just hope the next one has a bit more diversity in its soundtrack.

“Almost paaaaaaradise….!”

You Might Also Like

10 Comments

  • Reply kfangurl September 9, 2015 at 11:42 pm

    Fun read! 😀 Congrats on completing your first ever crack drama, Jami! *waves pompoms*

    I watched BOF at the height of BOF-mania, and was swept up along with everyone else. I remember also thinking that Ji Hoo looked better with the lighter hair. Now, though, I find it hard to rewatch BOF, even though I’ve found lots of other kdramas to love. Blame it on acquiring more discerning drama taste, I suppose..! 😉

    • Reply Jami McFeely September 10, 2015 at 1:35 pm

      Thanks! Hopefully I will move on to bigger and better Kdramas and look back on this with the same nostalgic shame others seem to!

  • Reply Brenda September 10, 2015 at 12:58 am

    This is one of the dumber kdramas, so it’s unfortunate that it’s one of your early ones. I promise they aren’t all as silly and hokey as this one.

    • Reply Jami McFeely September 10, 2015 at 1:34 pm

      I don’t mind silly and hokey so much, but it would be nice if things made just a tad more sense. 🙂

  • Reply justanotheranimefan September 10, 2015 at 10:31 am

    Oh get used to the flashbacks to the OMG WE LITERALLY JUST SAW THIS SCENE WHY THE HELL ARE WE FLASHBACKING AGAIN WRITERS WE ONLY HAVE THREE EPISODES LEFT WHY ARE YOU WASTING OUR PRECIOUS TIME, WE KNOW WHAT THE MAIN CHARACTER IS THINKING ABOUT (generally my reaction).

    Why did you think about the sudden plot development in the second last episode?

    • Reply Jami McFeely September 10, 2015 at 1:33 pm

      Oh no. Is that a constant thing with Kdramas? I think it would drive me nuts. BOF would have been 5 episodes shorter if they just trimmed all the montages and flashbacks. And – yes – it was amazing that they were still introducing characters and plot twists up to episode 24. Focus, people! Focus!

      • Reply justanotheranimefan September 12, 2015 at 10:51 am

        So far it’s happened in every series I watched, but some are worse at in that others. Some series will just replay the key spoken session rather than the whole scene again.

        I agree that this drama needed more focus! But I guess that’s mainly because it was adapted from a Japanese shoujo manga, and the writers probably wanted to fit everything in. Did you know that there are other adaptations of this storyline?

        • Reply Cherry Cordial September 15, 2015 at 1:16 am

          While flashbacks can be useful sometimes (remember that when the dramas air, it’s twice a week, and sometimes they need to remind you what happened) I suspect that a lot of them are just an easy way to fill time. Thinking about their live shoot system and when it’s getting closer to the end, I’m guessing sometimes it’s easier to fill that extra five minutes you’re short with an emotional flashback than shoot all new footage and race it back to the editing room.

  • Reply Purplerrr September 14, 2015 at 6:16 pm

    This post made me laugh as I LOATHED BOF. I’d taken a break from Kdrama for a couple of years and BOF was recommended to me as was You’re Beautiful and Foxy Lady aka What’s Up Fox. You’re Beautiful was my crack. I watched it straight through several times and bought the soundtrack. Yes it has a stupid if cute female lead but Jang Keun Suk was amazing.

    Foxy Lady still has some of the most frank sexuality talk I’ve seen in any Kdrama and laugh out loud images. Yet another stupid female lead but older and actually had a character arc where she grew.

    BOF I only made through 1/2 by fast forwarding and hating the whole time. I even mixed up discs 3 & 4 and it made very little difference in the story. I hope you find another drama without the flaws of BOF! There are some good ones out there.

    Welcome to the madhouse!

  • Reply Rebekah Roberts October 26, 2015 at 5:06 pm

    I cannot agree more. BOF is enjoyable, but in the end a little bit of a mess. You should definitely try a few more…as this is not the finest. I think what I liked most about this drama is Joon Pyo’s character growth, but by the end he had grown and Jun Di really had not…or worse she had declined as a character. I started out liking her a lot more than I did in the end… Where as I hated him but grew to love him as he grew from a teenage bully into a man. It was fun, but by no means great TV. LOL! Thanks for the review!! It was great to finally hear from the famous Jami McFeely.

  • Leave a Reply

    Back to top
    %d bloggers like this: